Find out how design choice, tiers, cake size, and more can all impact on your wedding cake budget

As you enter into the wonderful world of wedding planning, one sweet element always takes the spotlight—the wedding cake. But before you go wild ordering a multi-tiered wonder as tall as Ocean Resort Casino (or a sugary sculpture in the shape of your pet shih tzu), make sure that you get the lowdown on the potential cost of a wedding cake.

For instance, the average cost of a wedding cake in the USA is around $500, with couples typically budgeting between $300 to $700. But what can bring that price down or, alternatively, push it sky-high? Let’s explore five things that can influence how big a dent your wedding cake will make in your bank account (and if you’d like more help with your overall budget for your big day, check out our guide to average wedding costs in New Jersey).

1. Wedding cake size

There’s pretty much always going to be a connection between the grandeur of your cake and the grandness of your bill. It’s a straightforward equation—more tiers equal more ingredients, more labor, and ultimately, more cake to indulge in. So as you imagine your sweet centerpiece, take into account your guest count. If your wedding is on the smaller size, do you really need a giant cake? 

Plus bear in mind that size isn’t just about physical dimensions—it’s also about portion size. Do you envision serving your cake as the dessert with your meal, or will it be more of a decorative centerpiece? Understanding how your cake fits into the overall dining experience will help you decide on the appropriate size. In other words, if you’re planning to offer an array of treats (for instance, a dessert station), you may not need a massive cake to satisfy your guests’ sweet cravings.

And let’s not forget about storage space. A colossal cake requires ample room in both your venue and your refrigerator. So before committing to a jaw-dropping confection, speak to your venu and make sure that you have the capacity to accommodate it. Otherwise, you might find yourself scrambling for space—or worse, scrambling for a solution—on your big day.

In essence, while it’s tempting to go big or go home when it comes to wedding cakes, sometimes less is more. By carefully considering the size of your cake in relation to your guest count, dining preferences, venue constraints, and storage capabilities, you can ensure that your sweet centerpiece is as delightful to your budget as it is to your taste buds.

2. Wedding cake design

When it comes to wedding cakes, the design is where the overall theme and aesthetic of your big day comes to life. Whether you’re drawn to the simplicity of minimalist chic or the opulence of extravagant elegance, your cake’s design plays a pivotal role in setting the tone for your celebration.

Often, it’s the intricate details that steal the spotlight and capture the hearts of brides-to-be. Delicate lace patterns, hand-piped filigree, and meticulously crafted sugar flowers can all contribute to the overall allure of your cake. However, they all also come with a price tag to match. 

That said, there are also ways to achieve an eye-catching design without breaking the bank. Consider opting for simpler embellishments that still make a statement, such as textured buttercream or edible metallic accents. These elements can add visual interest and sophistication without the hefty price tag associated with more elaborate decorations.

Plus why not think outside the (cake) box when it comes to shape and structure? While traditional round or square tiers may be timeless classics, unique shapes like hexagons, ovals, or even asymmetrical designs can lend a modern twist to your confection. Not only do these unconventional shapes stand out visually, but they also offer opportunities for creative expression that can be tailored to suit your wedding theme.

And don’t overlook the importance of consultation and collaboration with your cake designer. By sharing your inspirations, preferences, and budget constraints upfront, you can work together to work out a design that strikes the perfect balance between beauty and affordability.

3. Artisan or mass-produced?

Are you torn between choosing a mass-produced cake from a commercial bakery or a bespoke design from an artisan creator? As choices go, it’s a delicate balance between cost and quality.

On one hand, opting for a mass-produced cake from a commercial bakery is definitely a budget-friendly choice. These bakeries usually offer standardized designs and production processes, resulting in lower costs for both materials and labor. However, while the initial price tag may be tempting—and while the cake might look pretty great—it’s good to consider the trade-offs involved. 

Mass-produced cakes lack the personal touch and customization options that come with working with a specialist baker. Your cake might not necessarily reflect your unique style and personality as a couple—or even your wedding theme. On the other hand, investing in a bespoke cake from a specialist baker may come with a higher price tag, but there are lots of benefits too. These talented artisans possess a wealth of experience and expertise, allowing them to bring your cake dreams to life with precision and artistry. 

From intricate sugar work to handcrafted details, every element of your cake can be thoughtfully designed. Working closely with a specialist baker enables you to collaborate on a custom design that speaks to your individual tastes and preferences, ensuring that your cake is truly one-of-a-kind. Whether you’re envisioning a romantic floral cascade, a contemporary geometric masterpiece, or a unique sculpted cake, a specialist baker has the skills and creativity to turn your ideas into reality.

Of course, there is no “right” answer on whether it’s best to go mass-produced or bespoke. Just start by figuring out how important your wedding cake is in terms of your overall look and theme, then budget from there. 

4. The flourish factor

Sugar flowers, fondant frills, edible gold—cake decorations don’t only look exquisite, they give you a chance to add your own individual statement and signature to your dessert centerpiece. For instance, delicate sugar flowers can be customized to match your wedding theme and color palette, creating a focal point filled with romance and charm. Whether you prefer a cascading cascade of roses or a subtle sprinkle of blossoms, hand-crafted sugar blooms offer endless possibilities for personalization and creativity.

Meanwhile, fondant frills and edible gold provide a touch of luxury and extravagance to your cake design. Fondant, a pliable sugar paste, can be sculpted into intricate patterns, ruffles, and textures, adding depth and dimension to your confection. From elaborate lace motifs to whimsical polka dots, fondant embellishments allow you to unleash your imagination and transform your cake into a work of art. Similarly, edible gold leaf or dust adds a shimmering finish to your cake, creating a sense of opulence and grandeur that is sure to impress your guests (and that would be ideal for a royal-themed wedding).

But as you know, bespoke and artisan decorations require time and specialist skills to create—meaning extra pressure on your budget. Each swirl and flourish is a labor of love from your cake artisan, requiring time, skill, and precision to bring your vision to fruition. For instance, it can take around an hour for an artisan baker to create a single sugar rose—which is why real flowers can save you a lot on price.

So if you’re looking for alternatives to high-concept or intricate designs, why not choose a rustic wedding cake? This choice is particularly ideal for weddings with a boho or nature-focused theme. Think charming and unpretentious cakes covered with fresh blooms, ferns. fruit, berries, ribbons, or a simple wedding cake topper. A rustic cake can be every bit as charming as a grand one—just without the hefty price tag. 

5. To tier or not to tier?

A tiered wedding cake is definitely the classic and traditional choice, yet bear in mind that the more tiers you include, the higher the cost. That’s because each tier requires additional ingredients, labor, and decorations. So before you order a towering spectacle the size of the Empire State Building, consider the impact on your budget. Also, consider whether alternatives such as a flat cake, simple one-tiered cake, or even a fun cupcake tower would work out better for you.

When it comes to deciding on tiers, you also want to think about guest count, venue size, and your overall wedding theme. If you’re throwing a big wedding and inviting every last cousin, then a multi-tiered cake may be needed to ensure there’s enough to go around. However, if you’re planning an intimate gathering with close friends and family, then you could go for a small and elegant cake.

You could also supplement a smaller cake with budget-friendly extras like cookies, cake pops, or fancy donuts—or you could even adopt the charming Southern tradition of including a groom’s cake. This way, you can enjoy the best of both worlds: an affordable display cake for cutting and photographs, with plenty of extras to make sure that your guests get their sugar rush.

Pick the wedding cake that’s right for you

In the end, it’s best to remember that your cake won’t last forever (except in photos, of course). It will soon be sliced up and wolfed down, so don’t feel pressure to go over the top if that’s not your style. Because whether you opt for a towering spectacle or a simpler choice, you’ll still satisfy everyone’s sweet tooth. 

And if you’d like more tips on designing the overall look and feel of your special day, check out our ultimate wedding decor checklist.

Ready for your big day?

Now that you’ve found inspiration from our wedding cake cost guide, it’s time to pick the perfect New Jersey wedding venue. Il Tulipano in Cedar Grove is ideal for a stylish ceremony and reception surrounded by Italian gardens. Our venue has just had a makeover and been praised by New Jersey Bride, The Knot, and Wedding Wire. The Il Tulipano team will treat you like family, so get in touch with us today and let’s plan your dream wedding.

Want more wedding tips? Head over to our blog.